Thirteen Minutes focused on weekly reviews of Creator-Owned Comics from 2005 to 2015. Critic @ Poopsheet Foundation 2009-2014. Critic @ Comics Bulletin 2013-2016. Freelance Writer/Editor @ DC/Vertigo, Stela, Madefire, Image Comics, Dark Horse, Boom! Studios, and Studio 12-7 from 2012-Present. Follow @ThirteenMinutes
8.22.2012
8.22.12 Reviews
Sponsor Plug: Special thanks to Michael Cholak, Owner of Yesteryear
Comics, for sponsoring this week’s review books. Make Yesteryear Comics your
first destination in San Diego for great customer service on a wide selection
of mainstream and independent titles at the best discounts possible. For a
limited time, new customers can enjoy a promotional 25% discount on new
releases, valid until September 30. After September, customers receive an
attractive 20% discount on new books during their first week of release.
Yesteryear Comics is located at 9353 Clairemont Mesa Blvd. in Kearny Mesa, or
find them online at www.yesteryear-comics.com
Scalped #60 (DC/Vertigo): If you’ve been riding shotgun with
me this long after reviewing every single issue of Scalped, then what the hell
is there left for me to say? The “Flaming Mexican Standoff” comes to a
conclusion, Red Crow popping Catcher, Dash clipping Red Crow, Dash only
finishing off Catcher in a righteous fury dream before Nitz does it for him and
seals his own fate in the process. Everyone turns out in this finale, from
Carol to Granny Poor Bear, RM Guera depicts them all in his visceral murky glory.
Catcher’s line about being a prophet or murderer underscores the remorseful
resignation of the entire tone, driving home the realization that our most
dangerous demon is the ability to justify our own actions, no matter what they
are. By the end, everyone ends up in a new place, perhaps where they best
belong. It’s “a place for the runaways and the utterly immovable, for the
stubborn and the bold, for the survivors and the damned, the full blooded and
the bled dry, the stone cold.” Fuckin’ A, nobody writes like that! It’s like
Jason Aaron has gone and saved his most representative bit of prose until the
very end; this last monologue by Dash is like some bastard son of Hemmingway
and Cormac McCarthy or Dashiell Hammett. Instead of trying to find something
new to say to sing it’s praises, let me think back on Scalped. There was a time
when Vertigo had a perfect trifecta of titles in DMZ, Scalped, and
Northlanders. That time has now come and gone. I doubt they’ll ever be that
strong again. It’s the end of an era for the imprint. I’m also a little
disturbed at the pattern forming, that DC is able to somehow push away their
best writers so that Marvel or other publishers snatch them up. If some executive
at HBO isn’t working day and night to bring Scalped to their line-up, well,
that’s just fucking stupid. After The Sopranos and Deadwood and Breaking Bad
and Game of Thrones and The Walking Dead, it’s just fucking ridiculous that
Scalped isn’t the next premium hit on TV. It’s perfect. I don’t use the “perfect”
word often, but Aaron’s dialogue was always perfect. It’s strong and memorable,
but not with the flowery sake of itself tang that Tarantino has. It’s rhythmic
and realistic, but not in the overly staged and contrived way that Sorkin or
Mamet is. It’s realistic in a way that you just feel in your guts. I don’t
remember an issue where Aaron poured so much of himself into the words, like
Catcher's lines about wanting to be a writer, about wanting to create when he’s
surrounded by nothing but a culture of destruction. There isn’t another book
that has such a palpable sense of unexpected danger lurking behind every page.
There are few pieces of art in pop culture that have the ability to transcend
their genre, to transcend their origin, and offer something more about a
segment of society. It’s things like The Godfather and Glengarry Glen Ross and
the commentary they told about the collapse of The American Dream. Scalped
enters that pantheon. It was a book that was on my best of the year list every
single year that it existed, and this year will be no different. Thank you for
one of the classics. If you’re into comics and you haven’t read, or are not at
least seriously planning to read Scalped, I just don’t think we can be friends
anymore. Grade A+.
Justin Giampaoli was an award-winning critic at Thirteen Minutes and Comics Bulletin for over a decade. As a writer, his most notable work includes the self-published crime caper The Mercy Killing with artist Tim Goodyear, introductions and bonus content for New York Times Bestseller DMZ at DC/Vertigo, the alt-history epic Rome West and the sci-fi drama Starship Down, both with artist Andrea Mutti at Dark Horse. Other writing and editorial credits include projects for Boom! Studios, Image Comics, and Madefire. Recently, he edited the geo-political thriller California, Inc. with writer Arthur Ebuen and artist Dave Law at Studio 12-7, and was a panelist at San Diego Comic Con 2024.
2 Comments:
Excellent review, Justin. You've hit the nail square on the head. I couldn't (and won't) say it better myself.
Thanks, Matt! I know we'll all sorely miss Scalped, but I'm trying to just be thankful we got it in the first place!
Post a Comment
<< Home